April 21st, 2012

Lizzie Borden and Dead Files

Let me offer this review of the latest foray into the paranormal with an investigation into the goings on at the Lizzie Borden Bed & Breakfast, which was aired Friday night (April 20, 2012) on the Travel Channel. The show in question is The Dead Files. If you have read my previous posting, before the airing of the episode, you can easily tell my bias. I am not a fan of this show. I want to be one. I keep trying to be one. But I am consistently disappointed by the high jinks of this supposed paranormal show and I have never made a public comment before now about it. But last night they tread on my territory and made fools of themselves in the process.

I am officially accusing this show of fraud. It is clear to me that these two investigators (one a NY homicide detective and the other a psychic) are in cahoots and do speak to one another before the big “reveal” at the end. There are too many roadsigns pointing me to this conclusion. Just take a look at the clips that were posted on the Travel Channel’s site for the show (and are linked at my previous post) to see the not so subtle way in which the detective hears the word poison, and the psychic feels the word poison. And yet, this all important segment does not make it into the final cut. I wonder why?

In addition to this fakery, there are other problems. The detective claims to have reviewed the case, studied it for clues perhaps not yet found, and is shown turning pages of newspaper clippings. Big deal. You cannot learn about a murder case from the Victorian era from the newspaper accounts. They are full of contrived bits and pieces, which made for great sales. Remember, this was right at the beginning of the yellow journalism craze. I have studied this case, ad nauseam studied this case, and one thing I know is that to learn about this murder you have to read the transcripts: the police witness statements, the inquest, the preliminary hearing, and the trial. Through sworn testimony can one glean some kernels of interesting facts that may actually assist you in your attempts to solve this most enigmatic of murder mysteries. But certainly not by using the newspapers, which, by the way, got it all wrong on the very first day they printed the story.

But the worst part of all was the ending. Here is the big “reveal” where the image that was dictated by the psychic to the sketch artist is compared to the “brand new never before seen” image that the detective has “uncovered.” As I waited with bated breath, he shows us an image that I recognize. It is Lizzie as an old woman, a brand new photo just published in the new book by the curatorial staff of the Fall River Historical Society. The book is Parallel Lives: A Social History of Lizzie A. Borden and Her Fall River.

How do I recognize her so quickly? I helped edit this book and wrote the index for it. So I have been involved in the project for some time.

I was APPALLED by the photoshopping that was done to this lovely image of a sweet old lady sitting on a bench in some lovely roadside park. They took off her hat. They changed the color of her hair from white to dark (to match the image done by the sketch artist) and changed the background. Very badly photoshopped I might add. If anything proves this show is a farce, a fake, and a fraud, then this image is the smoking gun.

These people should be ashamed of themselves.

Here is a screen grab of the image the detective reveals to us:

Here is a screen grab of the two images from the show side by side that they broadcasted:

And here, my friends, is the image, the REAL image from the book of Lizzie Borden as an old woman.

Now let me show you the real photo and the one they photoshopped for the show compared, side by side.

Notice how they changed the hat, the hair, the background. How they highlighted her features. Took away her glasses. Removed the car. Removed the trees. You can plainly see the deception.

My ire is ignited when they mess with Lizzie Borden’s story and try to gain viewers by deception. This is a serious case where two people were brutally murdered. And it cannot be told by two people who swoop into town, make wild assumptions, and then leave as quickly as they arrived. They are making fools of Fall River, of the Borden story, and of the Lizzie Borden Bed & Breakfast. And all of us deserve more.




April 20th, 2012

Lizzie Borden Mentioned in the May 2012 Smithsonian

Great Barrington, Massachusetts, was selected by the Smithsonian Magazine as the number one of the 20 best small towns in the United States. The article on these wonderful places appears in the May 2012 issue.

Of note to Borden folks is that Great Barrington was the home of Justice Justin Dewey, one of the three presiding judges in the trial of Lizzie Borden in 1893.

A little bio of Dewey is in order: this from the Glossary of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts VS. Lizzie A. Borden; The Knowlton Papers, 1892-1893. Eds. Michael Martins and Dennis A. Binette. Fall River, MA: Fall River Historical Society, 1994.

“DEWEY, JUSTIN 1836 – 1900: born in Alford, Massachusetts, son of Justin and Melinda (Kelsey) Dewey. He received his early education in the public schools of his native town and in Great Barrington, Massachusetts. He then attended Williams College, graduating in 1858. He began the study of law in the Great Barrington office of Increase Sumner, Esq., was admitted to the Berkshire bar in 1860 and subsequently established his own practice. He rose quickly to prominence in his chosen profession. He wed Miss Jane Stanley in Great Barrington in 1865. Active politically, he was elected to the Massachusetts House of Representatives in 1862 and again in 1877. He was also elected to the state senate in 1879. In 1886, he was appointed judge of the Massachusetts superior court by Governor George D. Robinson, the man who would later successfully defend Miss Lizzie A. Borden in the courtroom over which he presided. He died in Springfield, Massachusetts.”

The current inhabitants of the house wrote about their happy discovery to be in the magazine here, in the Berkshire Eagle.

From the Smithsonian Magazine online:

1. Great Barrington, MA
Big-city smart meets New England natural in an art-rich mountain setting.

You’ve got to slow down when Route 7 leaves behind the wide-open valley of the Housatonic River to enter Great Barrington. The road becomes Railroad Street there, right of way to pedestrians stalled in the crosswalk trying to decide whether to have sushi or chimichangas for dinner. Others carry yoga mats, bags of farmers market produce, books, CDs, double espressos and all the other stuff it’s hard to find in surrounding Berkshire Mountain villages like Stockbridge and Lenox.

Compared with them, Great Barrington (pop. 6,800) is like a big city where you can get anything you want, to borrow the chorus from “Alice’s Restaurant Massacree,” by hometown boy Arlo Guthrie. He was 18 when he wrote the satirical ballad about true events on Thanksgiving Day 1965, when he got arrested for illegally dumping some of Alice’s trash, ultimately making him ineligible for the Vietnam War draft. Trinity Church, former abode of the celebrated Alice, is now the Guthrie Center, a stage for folk music, starting point of the annual “Historic Garbage Trail Walk” and a place for interfaith spiritual exchange in a town where there could be something contrarian in the water.

Or in the food. At the forefront of the big-chain-grocery-store-defying, eat-local movement, Great Barrington is devoted to its family farms, farmers markets and co-op. Berkshire Grown, an organization that promotes the production and marketing of locally grown food, spreads the word with lectures by writers like Michael Pollan (The Omnivore’s Dilemma and most recently Food Rules).

Great Barrington’s latest unconventional endeavor is to mint its own currency, an experiment launched in 2006 aimed at getting people to buy everything—not just food— local. Almost 400 businesses in the area trade BerkShares bills; the 5 BerkShares note features W.E.B. Du Bois, the great African-American author and educator whose boyhood home just west of town is a National Historic Landmark.

Incorporated in 1761, around the same time as Stockbridge and Lenox, Great Barrington, too, attracted rich summer people who built Gilded Age mansions like Searles Castle, now a boarding school. But Great Barrington grew up as a mill and railroad center, its blue-collar ring never excised. About 125 miles from New York City, it attracts a hip crowd from the Big Apple, along with New Englanders and recent immigrants from Asia and Mexico.

“Great Barrington is a small, manageable, economically and ethnically mixed town. That’s what I love about it,” says locally renowned Northeast Public Radio director and commentator Alan Chartock, who proudly lives in a house once owned by one of the judges at the Lizzie Borden trial.

When passenger trains still stopped in town, they brought performers from New York, booked to appear at the Mahaiwe, a vintage 1905 vaudeville theater. Now lovingly restored, it offers a year-round schedule of jazz, rock, dance, lectures and HD broadcasts from London’s National Theater and New York’s Metropolitan Opera. Executive Director Beryl Jolly, who came to Great Barrington from New York’s Public Theater, calls it the Mahaiwe Mix, no categories excluded, for the whole “big mix of people you see walking down Railroad Street.”

Early summer brings the Berkshire International Film Festival to the Triplex Cinema, and classical music performed on historic instruments to the Aston Magna Festival at the Bard College Simon’s Rock campus. Not to mention such famous cultural institutions as Tanglewood, Shakespeare & Company, the Norman Rockwell Museum and Jacob’s Pillow Dance Festival just a country drive away.

Then there’s the frame that nature put around the picture, with 1,642-foot Monument Mountain to the east and the rest of the Berkshires to the west—such cozy mountains! Orchards are sheer walls of pink in the spring, farm fields thick with corn in the summer. Fall leaf-peepers train cameras on golden oaks and crimson maples. Honking geese pass over ice-coated bogs and ponds in the watershed of the Housatonic River. All this, and bagels, too. Arlo got it right. — Susan Spanov

You can read about the magazine’s criteria here, and the full article here.




April 20th, 2012

Lizzie Borden Case on Travel Channel Tonight

Tonight on the Travel Channel is an episode of “Dead Files” that centers on the Borden case and was filmed at the Lizzie Borden Bed & Breakfast here in Fall River, MA.

I have tried in the past to watch this show and I have to admit that I find it deadly dull. The way this paranormal show works is that there is a NY city detective and a psychic that each, separately they claim, investigate the location/case and then come together at the end to try to solve the investigation and share their findings.

Always excited about a new show on Lizzie Borden, I have been very disappointed with the clips I have seen thus far.

In one, the detective interviews Shelley Dziedzic, who works at the house and knows her stuff about the case. She tells the story of Abby going across the street to Dr. Bowen’s house on the day before the murders to tell him that she fears she is being poisoned. They cut her there and the camera then shows the detective’s face looking very serious and startled, like he just heard something that NOBODY has ever heard before and that this is a HUGE CLUE to solving the case.

Well, if they would have let Shelley FINISH the story, they might have learned that this complaint of being “poisoned” was quite common in that day and time, when home refrigeration was at its infancy and food spoiled. People got sick from their diets on a regular basis, especially in the summer. So much so, in fact, that this type of illness was referred to as the “summer complaint.”

Yet it looks like this detective socks this info about “poisoning” away and seems in this clip to be on to something!

Then the psychic is shown on the third floor, in a room that was a storage space in 1892, forming her impressions. She claims she senses people “throwing up” and utters the word “poisoned” very meekly, almost as if to slip it into the conversation. Of course, this comes after we have heard Shelley’s story and the importance of the word becomes underlined and magnified.

This clip is probably the one that made me laugh out loud the most. To me, it proves that these two speak to one another before they go on camera and have done some research before their visits to throw in little bits of history to make their investigations seem realistic.

The hoax is complete with just these short clips. The detective pronounces that his “GUT” tells him that Lizzie’s acquittal might just have been a miscarriage of justice and that the jury got it wrong. His gut. GodblessAmerica. His gut.

This case has been investigated TO DEATH, and nobody is able to solve it, mainly because there really isn’t any evidence to convict anyone of the crimes. And trust me, nobody’s GUT is going to solve this case either. Not when they swoop in and then swoop out of town like they did.

The show is laughable. Boring and laughable.

But you should see it for yourself. You be the judge. But know this: you have been warned!

Here is clip #1

Here is clip #2.

Here is clip #3.

Here is clip #4.

Oh, and they get some facts wrong too! And throw in the whole incest theory to boot!




April 6th, 2012

Bridget Sullivan in her later years

After extensive conversations with the relatives of the Borden maid Bridget Sulilvan, who live in Anaconda, MT and California, I am releasing two photos of Bridget Sullivan in advance of an article that will be appearing in the next issue of The Hatchet on her.

In the first image we see Bridget with her husband John Sullivan. In the second, a solo of Mrs. Sullivan, apparently standing at the same gate in front of her home in Anaconda. Click on the images to see them in full.




April 2nd, 2012

Lizzie Borden Roundup

I didn’t want to post anything yesterday for fear my readers would assume it was an April Fool’s post. Don’t get me wrong, I love to read really good Fool’s Day punks. But I have been tricked into thinking so many things that are not true (they say I am gullible) that it is best if I left all that falderal to the big boys and experts.

There are a few smaller items to report on in Lizzie land, so without further ado, here they are:

From the Laconia Daily Sun:

On April 19 at 7 p.m. the Bristol Historical Society and the Friends of the Library together are presenting “Lizzie Borden Took Her Ax, Or Did She?” For over one hundred years the gruesome murders of Lizzie’s father and stepmother have elicited belief in both Lizzie’s innocence and her guilt. Professor Annette Holba of PSU will present the facts, the evidence, and the fascinating history of this mystery. This program will be held at the Bristol Old Town Hall and is free to all. The Minot-Sleeper Library in Bristol, NH.

From Broadwayworld.com:

“Travel Channel brings back an all-new season of its compelling one-hour paranormal investigative series THE DEAD FILES featuring retired NYPD Homicide Detective Steve DiSchiavi and medium Amy Allan as they travel throughout the country to uncover the unexplained disturbances in each locale. The new thirteen-episode season kicks off on Friday, April 20 at 10:00 p.m., ET/PT with a special one hour investigation of the notorious Lizzie Borden House, and once again, pairs the no-nonsense detective, who investigates physical evidence, with the gifted medium, who channels the dead. They explore each crime scene separately from each other, joining together only at the end to compare notes and deliver some startling results to the homeowner.

Season two premieres with an astonishing examination of the Lizzie Borden House in Massachusetts – a residence made infamous by the vicious, gruesome and still-unsolved murders that occurred there back in 1892. Now an inn, frightening new claims of violent attacks and ominous apparitions propel Allan and DiSchiavi into a disturbing investigation as they attempt to unravel the mystery and paranormal activity that has plagued this spot for generations. While Allan is eager to push the limits of her unique powers, DiSchiavi digs deeper into the facts, legends and lies surrounding the house. Their unsettling findings shock the inn’s owner as they uncover a bizarre new twist to a century-old murder mystery.”

In Parsippany, NJ:

The Lizzie Borden Case: A Paranormal Case Study
Main Library , 449 Halsey Road, Parsippany 07054 (US).
(973) 887-5150
Date: 30 Apr, 2012
Time: 07:00 – 08:30

449 Halsey Rd
Parsippany, NJ 07054

Event description:
Al Rauber, a paranormal researcher for over 40 years investigated the murder site at 92 Second Street for two different TV production companies to see if any evidence pointed to the house being haunted using electronic voice phenomena.

Rauber will explain the case for and against Lizzie being the murderer and how other suspects figure into the story. He has been feature on The History Channel and The Travel Channel and is co-founder of Haunted New Jersey.

Registration is strongly recommended. Please contact Judy Fenelon at 973-887-5150 x211 by April 28th.

Al Rauber is a good friend of mine and his presentations are top notch. If you are in the area, you must go!

And this from YouTube:

“On feb 28th Neath college Extended Drama Level 3 group put on a show of Lizzie Borden. A dark story about a young girl who murderd her parents in USA in 1800s this was a true story and the case is still open today. these are a few photos from rehersyls [sic].”




March 12th, 2012

Central Congregational Church Spared For Now

It seems that until the bank, which owns the old Central Congregational Church, can pay its back taxes in full, the wrecking ball will not be permitted to strike down the structure. This is fairly good news for those of us who love this building, and would love this building whether it had a connection to Lizzie Borden or not. Too many of the churches of Fall River are gone—by fire, demolition, human greed, or development. In recent years, there have been several such destructions, to old churches that could have been far more easily repurposed than the CCC on Rock Street. Yet, they are gone. Forever. In their place are parking lots and other less lovely spaces.

But the Central Congregational Church is extra special. It is an architectural beauty. And it hasn’t been a church for many years, already being utilized as a restaurant, a wedding location, a culinary school, and a sometime music video location.

You can read all about the latest news of the old building in today’s Fall River Herald News.



March 12th, 2012

The Mary Sue Does Lizzie Borden

Appearing today on The Mary Sue: A Guide to Girl Geek Culture, is an article on the recent acquisition by the Fall River Historical Society of Andrew Jennings’ notebooks from the defense case of Lizzie Borden.

Enjoy!



March 12th, 2012

Timeline of Legal Chronology of Lizzie Borden Case




March 12th, 2012

Lizzie Borden’s Lawyer’s Notebooks in Boston Globe

Monday, March 12, 2012 issue of the Boston Globe has an article on the recent acquisition of Lizzie Borden’s lawyer’s notebooks, made during the trial. Andrew Jennings was the Borden family attorney and lead defense member all during her legal troubles. While he did not take the lead in the trial itself, the family having hired a big gun in the name of former governor of Massachusetts George Dexter Robinson, Jennings remained an invaluable asset to Lizzie’s defense.

Here is the article. It may be behind a paywall.

March 6th, 2012

Fall River Revisited Available for Preorder

You can preorder Fall River Revisted on Amazon.com

I am very proud of this work. It represents a great coming together of Fall River historians and collectors. The members of the Fall River History Club were instrumental in making this happen. And a big THANK YOU to the Fall River Historical Society for their contribution!



WP Like Button Plugin by Free WordPress Templates